Sunday 25 June 2017

May Day Thoughts on Hapless Truck Drivers



Army recruitment drive somewhere in India


Ramesh Kumar from New Delhi

Every job is challenging. The difference is in degrees. Truck driving falls in the more challenging category in comparison with babus behind desk with computers or blue collar workforce at factories, or healthcare professionals at hospitals or educationalists at their citadels or sanitary staff at municipalities.

The most challenging, in my reckoning, is the role of defense forces because they enroll in this career knowing fully well that they are willingly signing their own death warrant.

Yet, millions flock to recruitment camps, held on weekends at district playgrounds across India at regular intervals. Metro dwellers may not witness this spectacle but it is a reality. Those who get selected rejoice and the rejects curse their fate and return home with a desire to return soon after improving their physical fitness. Yes, their maiden bridge to cross is this critical aspect.

What attracts these swarming army of wannabe fauji (both men and women) to a career in defending the country? Patriotism? Nah. It's a preferred career option. Why? Once you get selected, the future is assured. The Nation takes care of you. 

The recruit may become a cook or driver or artillery gunner what not. The whole nine yards. Am talking at the grassroot level. I recall what (Retd) Col. H P Sharma at Army Welfare Placement Organization, helping ex-servicemen with jobs in civil India saying: "Except teaching accounts, we do everything under the sun." So when they exit the services, choices before them career wise is wide. That's what Col. Sharma was trying to impress.

Simply put, the Indian defense sector attracts millions from remote villages to try their luck because their future is taken care of. Added advantage is the respect the civil society bestows on them, unless and until they misbehave.

The Nation's concern - the ruling elite marshalling the tax payer's money (yours and mine, of course!) - about them right from day one of their joining the forces till their departure for their heavenly abode via natural route or in action is astounding. It ought to be.

Leave aside for a moment, the fauji. Even the white collar - absorbed via contracts or proper appointment - enjoy regular monthly salary, social benefits (provident fund, healthcare insurance including accident/death coverage), weekly offs, a slew of leave of absence - casual, sick and privilege. Or take the workmen at factories whose interests are protected through various labor legislative pieces. And, the quintessential trade unions to ensure these men and women are not exploited and their rights are not usurped.

Brothers Vikram and Raju Singh from Bheem, Rajasthan into long haul trucking, the author travelled with in 2012


Now, come to the world of long haul truck drivers.

It's a different world. Is there any recruitment process? No. Then how come 2.5 million heavy commercial vehicles are plying on Indian highways? Are they driverless trucks? You must be joking. No driverless trucks, for sure. They will not descend on the Indian soil for a decade at least in my reckoning.

The truck driver recruitment process is simple: someone in the mohalla happens to be a driver with no pucca training but learnt via On The Job Training mode or OJT as popularly known. Another reason for this OJT route is the total absence of Driver Training Institutes (DTIs) to impart formal driving education since the advent of trucking in India more than a century ago.

This OJT driver, mostly uneducated or less educated, seems to have built a career splendidly. With no industrialization in the vicinity, village youth loitering with no job in sight are goaded by the family to try their hands at truck driving. No education required. Look at Chacha Abdullah or Parkash or Velumani. They made a career. Look at the living standards of their parivar. They are well off. Give it a try, beta!

OJT Chachas also tell them: "Come. See hamara desh (from the driver's cabin). Free of cost. In the process, learn driving. I will teach you. Of course, I will take care of food etc when you travel with me." The reluctant kid from dehat hops into the cabin for his free Bharat darshan to explore a new career disinterestedly to begin with. If he likes the journey and cherishes what he does (learning to drive a truck) and the kind of money he can make when he turns a full fledged driver - a year down the line - he is set. That's how truck drivers in India germinate. Or, after one or two trips, he is off the truck. Not my cup of chai, Chachu! Back to idling at dehat. 

When he takes up truck driving as a career, he comes to term with the ground reality. What he heard from Chachu is not all that rosy. What he sees sitting next to him while on the drive is something different. Plenty of gaping holes. There is no job security. No social benefits. Your earning comes from every single km driven with load. No load, no payment. Fall sick and can't drive. Sorry, no earnings. There is a wedding in the family and your presence is required for a month or so. Go away. No drive, no earnings. Or death in the family. Ditto.

Forget about job security. What about his own personal safety? Recall what happened during the recent farmers' agitation in Madhya Pradesh. Trucks were looted and torched. Drivers have to jump and run away to save their precious lives. En route, hit a goat or chicken or a human being while passing through the villages as part of National or State Highways. The locals will lynch you. It is driver vs the mob. Or take the empty highways nestling amongst forests that he has to cross at nights. He will be waylaid by hijackers. Drugged, looted and killed at times. Right Ramrattan Singhi?

When he dies what happens? Nothing. Fleet owner mostly will arrange for the body to be carted to his hometown from the accident/death site and a few thousand rupees to the bereaved family for cremation. That's it. Period. Who is bothered about the future of the driver's family? None. Ram naam sathya hai! Or if his limbs are lost, believe me that's the end of his career as truck driver. Insurance? Haha. Do you ask me about various insurance schemes rolled out by government? 99% of long haul drivers have no idea. No promotion. Neither by the insurance companies (mostly PSUs). Nor by motor maliks.

That's the owners' attitude whom these drivers serve with no piece of paper to support. What about the consignor or consignee whose survival depends on these drivers in this age of outsourcing? Pathetic. No rest rooms when these drivers reach destination for loading or unloading. There is no concept of detention time, thanks to inefficient 3PLs. So during the waiting period, they defecate in the open, fertilizing the surroundings of India Inc whose CSR spend is large, no doubt. Are they not aware of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Swatch Bharat Abhiyan? Is he going to come and check outside factory gates of India Inc? No way. He is trusting these educated lot will help him build a better India. If they turn a blind eye, how can he be held accountable?

Okay. What about the en route experience of drivers? Less said, the better. There are 18 vultures on the highways, it is said. "Vultures" is the euphemism for rent-seeking sarkari babus representing various wings of federal or state governments. Taking advantage of the lack of education and therefore their lack of awareness of document of vehicle, cargo and their own, they will be fleeced. Not to forget is the poor attention to the CMVR norms by their motor maliks and themselves. All these provide fertile ground for these vultures to loot. That's the bribery part. Hello, by the way, the Republic of India is NOT a single unit, but actually it is United States of India: 29 or 30 odd states with their own piece of legislation!

When white collar staff travel on work, are they not entitled to traveling and dear allowance (TA/DA)? And when they travel do they sleep on the railway platform or airport lounges or inter state bus terminus benches? We all know the answer. But drivers on duty have no rest room facilities en route. Even when they reach the destination - loading or unloading point - no waiting shed or rest room for toilets or washroom.They are something like the caravan serai of yore. Park wherever and exist. Period.

Another biggest missing element is lack of respect bestowed on this profession. Want proof? The moment a young driver decides to get married, there are no parents willing for "kanyadhan" (betrothal of their daughter). Why? Because truck driving is not a respectable profession. Social stigma. 

In a nutshell, truck driving offers no job security. no benefits. no social status, and no respect. Still men from dehat opt for this thankless job because the opportunity cost is very high. Become a truck driver and lead a comparatively better life vis a vis his neighbor engaged in farming that is seasonal and poor earning.

Federal Minister for Transport Nitin Gadkari keeps harping on 22% driver shortage in the country. Under Skill India, the government is exploring to bridge this gap via the setting up of Driver Training Institutes. Good initiative.

But is this drive adequate? Sufficient? Not at all. This Skill India initiative is trying to address a miniscule challenge. Put it differently, it touches the tip of the iceberg.

Creation of DTIs alone is not the panacea.

Then what? The need of the hour is a fulsome approach, involving various stakeholders. Yes, a social transformation, if one can say so. No jokes. Because, the future is alarming if the driver shortage is not bridged. Yes, Gadkari is keen on promoting multimodal mix to reduce the dependence on road transport (read trucks). That's a long term goal. Coastal shipping, rail logistics are all fine. But the first and last mile connectivity has to be through trucks. That too with drivers at the wheels. Not driverless trucks!

Why am I talking about fulsome social transformation? Let me put it this way. Right from the occupant of Rashtrapati Bhavan in Lutyen's Delhi to Chacha Abdullah in his Azamgarh basti has to go on a frantic food hunting when trucks go off the roads protesting against something or other. Suddenly, essential items price spiral. Healthcare institutions will face medicine shortage. Political masters get jittery as vote banks turn hostile. The nation is always in election mode at the state or federal or local level.

Mami Ambuja in Mylapore and Aunty Nandini Kaur in Chandigarh will find their fridges empty with no milk, no vegetables, no paneer. Kartar Singh Ahluwalia in Mumbai and Soumitra Banerjee in Salt Lake will try to acquire their nightcap (read liquor) at whatever price even. All because Chacha Abdullah and his ilk have switched off their engines and  taken their feet off accelerator for a few days even if it means loss of income for the days their vehicles won't move an inch. 

Forget about everything. India Inc will face the music severely. In this age of Just In Time or Zero Inventory and outsourcing model, their assembly lines will grind to a halt when trucks go off the road.

Trucking or transportation is the backbone of any economy. India is no exception. Here again, transportation has to be understood in the right perspective. Not the HCV OEMs alone. Not the fleet owners only. Not the light asset management agency type transporters only. Not the agents or brokers alone. But the key player is the man behind the wheels. Truck drivers.

Transportmitra Services Founder Selvan Dasaraj (Disclaimer: this writer is the CoFounder - www.transportmitra.com - as well), keen on addressing the shortage issue realized that this challenge will remain unmet unless and until the anomalies in the way the current truck drivers are rectified by the society.

Why millions flock to army recruitment jamborees? Commonsense tells you  that the service conditions are good and a career path is shown. Plus post retirement benefits spelt out clearly. Nothing to worry.  Mein hoon na? Similarly, when basic issues are addressed with sincerity by all stakeholders - not the government alone -  the village youth will explore truck driving as a career option genuinely.

Okay, what needs to be done? What's the Laundry List? 

 The responsibilities can be put into three baskets viz.,

a) The Government
b) Fleet Owners/Transporters/Brokers/Agents
c) End Users (consignor & consignee)

The government has to ENSURE the provisions of Transport Workers Act 1961 is implemented in letter and spirit. It contains everything including wayside amenities, working hours, resting, social benefits etc. But, there is no monitoring and implementing with the result this segment, second only to agriculture in terms of providing massive job opportunity directly and indirectly, remains unorganized and therefore indisciplined. By the way, the truck drivers are not unionized at the scale of transporters, brokers, fleet owners. A unionized truck driver fraternity  is feared at and viewed as an evil and hence fleet owners, transporters prefer the status quo is maintained. Sheer self interest with poor long term vision.

Fleet owners have to get into a concrete working arrangement via written employment papers with social benefits such as Provident Fund, Healthcare, Accident/Death Insurance, Working Hours, etc. It is no use claiming that drivers are comfortable with the existing working relationship with per km basis. Most of the fleet owners are fully unaware of CMVR norms. If that is the case, how can they monitor their vehicles and drivers are law-abiding? So, fleet owners need education first. Remember a major chunk of fleet owners are owner-cum-drivers with little or no education to boast of. It is a challenge.

Last, but not the least, is the role of consignor and consignee. Here I mostly refer to the behavior of India Inc -the ultimate beneficiary or end user of transportation services. These giants with multilocation manufacturing facilities and huge budgets for  mandated CSR spends turn a blind eye to creating driver rest room facilities outside their own factories. Reason:  they claim transportation has been outsourced and therefore it is not their responsibility. Sad, these rich and educated owners and managers of these billion rupees business enterprises need a stick - not a gentle prodding - to become better corporate citizens. 

This segment believes in adopting villages than creating basic toilets and rest room facilities outside their own factory gates. Why? Village adoption gets more publicity. Not creating toilets outside factory gates. Pathetic and pitiable. This segment also needs awakening.

Career path is something that needs to be addressed for truck drivers as well. Why a 15-20 year old experienced driver be equated with a rookie? Why both be bracketed as driver? Even someone joining as a cook or driver in defense forces, he progresses in his career. His designations change. Role changes. At the time of retirement he is no longer the cook or driver he was recruited. He retires as Subedar. With a life long pension and free medical facility for him and his family.

Truck driver is just that: no seniority. No worktime benefits. Nor post-retirement benefits.

It is a tough call for the entire society to change its attitude towards truck drivers. But worth trying.

When these changes are brought about, the driver shortage will vanish on its own. Better working and living conditions will automatically draw freshers to this profession.

Remember that we are in the midst of Make In India journey with the grandiose plan to spike contribution of manufacturing to GDP from 16% to 25% . Basically this is all about making physical or tangible goods to meet the needs of 1.2 billion populace that needs to be clothed, fed and nurtured in this age of decreasing mortality or increased longevity of life. Items are to be manufactured and distributed pan India.

Roads have become better. Trucks have become better. But the treatment meted out to drivers remains unchanged. Even those opting for driving career would prefer to steering Olas and Ubers in cities for obvious reasons. Not the trucks of Tatas. Not Leyland. Not Eicher. Not Bharat Benz. Not Scania on highways far away from home for long stretches and treated shabbily  by all and sundry. 

Create this basic mindset change and begin to adopt a humanly approach towards truck drivers. Then DTIs will begin to get candidates. Mobilization of candidates will become a child's play. Today it is not. DTIs are unable to survive due to mobilization challenge. Why would anyone want to be a truck driver if the working and living conditions are worse? It is not aspirational yet. It's that simple.

The government, primarily, should turn its spotlight on improving the working and living conditions of current truck drivers. When they feel they are treated well, the viral effect will be phenomenal. The result will be positive. For this to happen, the government should prick the conscience of all stake holders and make them fall in line. All in the overall interest of economic growth.

When that happens, the Recruitment Drive for Truck Drivers at district headquarters on weekends will become something like what we are witness to army recruitment drive today. Millions will flock to these jamborees. And the 27% driver shortage will vanish into thin air.  Are we ready?

The writer is the author of 10,000 KM on Indian Highways, Naked Banana! and An Affair With Indian Highways. He has traveled 28,000 KM in trucks since 2010. He also found and manages KRK Foundation, a registered NGO focused in improving the working and living conditions of  long haul truck drivers and their families living in remote villages of India. He is Co-Founder of Transportmitra Services P Ltd (www.transportmitra.com) and edits DRIVERS DUNIYA, India's FIRST English Quarterly focused on truck drivers. He is reachable at ramesh@konsultramesh.com

Thursday 22 June 2017

Why I Am pissed off with TISS...




Ramesh Kumar from New Delhi


Is Driverless Truck Desirable in India?

This question arises in the wake of recent comments heard from the corridors of Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai that the driver shortage will soon be mitigated through two developments viz.,

1) The advent of Driverless Trucks
2) Rivigo

Oh, really?

This response of a panel of honorable social scientists came during an interview with a 40-year old supply chain veteran when he had submitted his proposal for a Ph.D thesis on the need for creating better working and living conditions  for long haul  drivers and thereby mitigate the looming shortage.

By the way, the wannabe Doctorate supply chain practitioner is yet to recover from the shock administered by the brainy TISS team. My first reaction was their lack of touch with ground reality. Literally, I was unequivocally pissed off with  TISS.

The Ministry of Road Transport & Highways (MoRT&H) has been maintaining that the shortage is pegged at 27% as of today. A monumental figure. Considering that the sale of heavy commercial vehicles (trucks in common parlance) in FY 15-16 was approximately 7,00,000 according to Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (SIAM) and the projected CAGR of 12-14% every year here onwards, India needs the same number of fresh Formally Trained Drivers (FTDs) every year. Yes, every year! Despite the grandiose promotion of multimodal mix of rail and coastal shipping, surface or road transport continues to hog 60% freight movement.
Enough of number crunching. Now onto the ground...

Who gets into long haul truck driving? Not the padhe likhe sort. Truck driving as a career option does not appear on the  radar of even Class 10 failed from the underprivileged segment of society. A microscopic examination of those who are already into this profession willingly or unwillingly reveals that most school information is mostly fake, manufactured by the touts at RTOs helping  them get a driving licence with no formal training. It is altogether another pitable story that India has no formal driver training institutes (DTIs). A few by Ashok Leyland, Tata Motors, IL&FS, Eicher Volvo is a nano-drop in the ocean.

What's the employment scenario? An alarming rising proportion, notwithstanding the laudable GDP growth. Alarming? Because it is more or less jobless growth, thanks to automation, partly and other factors. Even here, we are mostly talking about those who have been "educated" in the formal sense. A degree in hand. Just a piece of paper, which was once considered an an automatic passport to job market. No longer. 

A sizeable chunk from hinterland stay away from education per se. So, their absorption into formal job market is negligible. This is where the TISS contention that the driver shortage is a short term phenomenon and will get addressed over the next 5-6 years via the introduction of driverless trucks gives a wild ass kick. Not, the kickass thrill!

Surprisingly, these social scientists have not understood the social implications of shutting the doors of job opportunity for these less privileged (read illiterate or less educated) for whom truck driving is a good option. Even from the political perspective, it will be a disaster for parties when the government greenlights driverless trucks in India.
It would be suicidal even otherwise. Here is a golden opportunity to absorb the steady stream of candidates favorably considering truck driving as a career option - as a last resort, though. Yes, it is a fact of life that those getting into the profession do not cherish the classroom formal training and prefer the guru-shisya route that is in vogue since the advent of trucking in India, courtesy the British that had brought trucks for its troop movement more than a century ago.

But their aversion towards formal driver training can be overcome. It is  noteworthy here to draw attention to the fact that better educated set is exploring truck driving as a career option. This writer has met graduates in remote villages either already driving trucks and showing interest. The advent of onboard electronic management in Indian trucks certainly needs a better educated lot vis-a-vis the present one.

Another insight worth noting is the reluctance of truck manufacturers to implement the recent compulsory airconditioning of truck cabins citing that fleet owners do not wish to bear this additional spend. Even fleet owners arguing that their drivers prefer non-airconditioned variety. Nonetheless, it is mandatory to improve the working conditions of long haul truck drivers. If they are not used to airconditioned trucks, they will get used to it sooner than later.

Are the fleet owners not shifted from dungeon narrow gullies of Mahipalpur to swanky centrally airconditioned  offices in Gurgaon or Punjabibagh - some with glass-fronted cabins trying to show they have come off age? If they can, why not their drivers? What is missing is the will to act upon and improve. Not as charity. But out  of sustaining their business. Remember the government admits there is a 27% shortage. What's the point  of buying a truck if there are none to steer it? Got it?

Cost factor is the real issue here. Indian fleet owners, it is agreed, do not want to spend a Rs.50,000 towards aircondioning of truck cabins. It is a small sum. Now, examine the cost of driverless truck. Indian fleet owners will collapse when they see the price tag. Even a hefty discount, which is most likely, as an introductory offer as and when it comes to India will render our fleet owners breathless.

Conceding that driverless trucks would reduce human error - a major element in road accidents - Indian traffic discipline in cities or highways is  nothing to gloat. Unlike, Otto driverless trucks ferrying Carlsberg beer consignment in the United States, where there is a greater sense  of traffic discipline, it is dreadful to imagine a load of Nissan-Renault's most popular Kwid loaded car carrier plying on the south-north highway corridor without a driver at the steering. We, Indians (including the well educated), are not a disciplined lot.

Now, let us move on to the second pearl of wisdom from the TISS panel. Rivigo is one of the start-ups in transport ecosystem that is making waves with its comparatively more driver-friendly approach with its 2,000 plus owned fleet. Indeed, a welcome scenario. I can declare that Rivigo's arrival has rattled the entire conventional transport fraternity. Mera kya hoga? syndrome.

Yes, Rivigo is a fresh breath of air. But one swallow does not make summer. Is there a possibility of Rivigo clones on the Indian transport firmament? Yes. Over long term. I mean long term in the Keynesian parlance. Remember what he had said: In the long run, we are all dead.

Why Rivigo model is tough to copy? It is an asset heavy business enterprise. Indian transport segment - not bestowed the industry status - is more of agents (small, medium, large) and companies practizing light asset model, owning a miniscule number of trucks to get the transporter tag and mostly accessing trucks owned by others who again can boast of 5-10 or even less. With no business acument to procure business and manage, they are comfortable going through the time tested management agency system. End users (read the India Inc) is equally  blameworthy whose tariff fixation is a gamble playing in their favour. They take advantage of the pathetic demand-supply mismatch. Take it or leave it approach, thus making fleet owners who are the backbone of any economy as beggars. This kind of approach cannot be sustained for long.

By the way, there are hushed conversations in the smoking corners or watering holes or vast lawns of IIT-IIMs that are incubating start ups in the transport ecosystem among other things that the day is not far off when graduates will get into truck driving because that is the only ready career option available. Air conditioned cabins. Wow. And Rivigo type driver-friendly management. Far away from the current motor malik-chalak rishta. Plus, actually, truck driver earning capacity is far better than the non-existent formal sector jobs. (My own study of over 100,000 truck drivers over the past seven years confirms that a long haul truck driver walks away with approx. Rs.30,000 every month though there is no formal letter of appointment. An enticing package!)

Driverless trucks is a pill that TISS can swallow and theorize. Not the occupant - whoever it is and whichever political party - of 7 Lok Kalyan Marg. The Bharat will erupt. I repeat, the Bharat where two thirds of Republic of India lives. It is a lunatic concept from the Indian perspective. Wish, am wrong. Strange such ideas germinate from the portals of TISS!

--
The writer is Editor of DRIVERS DUNIYA, India's FIRST magazine in English focused on long haul truck driving community. He has travelled 28,000 km in trucks on Indian Highways and authored three books. Plus, he is the Co-promoter of TransportMitra Private Limited. He is reachable at ramesh@konsultramesh.com

Sunday 18 June 2017

How to SUBSCRIBE to DRIVERS DUNIYA ...


Hi folks,

Greetings.

First things, first.

DRIVERS DUNIYA is India's FIRST English magazine focused on the working and living conditions of long haul truck drivers in India.

It is a QUARTERLY, published every March, June, September & December.

Each hard copy issue is priced Rs.100/- (approx. US$1.53).

Annual Subscription is Rs.300/- (4 issues of Hard Copy in India only)

However, to save trees, there is an offer of Soft copy as well. At much cheaper price.

Annual Subscription is Rs.150/- (4 issues of Soft Copy across the world)

Okay.

Now, How to subscribe?

1) Pay through electronic transfer via legal banking channels.  The banking details are as under:

Account Name: KRK ASSOCIATES
Bank: HDFC BANK
Branch: MEHRAULI, NEW DELHI
Account No. 1 6 7 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 4 0 7
RTGS / NEFT IFSC : HDFC0001671

Post e-transfer, kindly scan receipt of payment slip and whatsapp/mail me for EASY IDENTIFICATION of Subscriber

2) Those who want to pay via PayTM, you can via +919711544181

3) Those who want to send Demand Draft, bank details are the same as above. My mailing address:

Ramesh Kumar
Deep Apartment
52 Ward No.1
Behind Punjab National Bank
Mehrauli, New Delhi 110030
Mobile: 9711544181

 DRIVERS DUNIYA is a unique media platform touching the lives of the key supply chain element: truck drivers.


They are the backbone of any economy. Ignore them at one's own peril.

Support DRIVERS DUNIYA with your subscription - Soft or Hard Copy. Choice is YOURS.

Thanks
Ramesh Kumar
Editor